The Dark Origin of Tolkien’s Orcs: Exploring Canon and Controversy

By Bobby Darvish, Iranian-American Ex-Muslim, Former Vegan, Former Democrat, Former Socialist, Former CAIR-Columbus Executive Director, Former Muslim Forum of Utah President, Christian Conservative LDS

J.R.R. Tolkien, the mastermind behind The Lord of the Rings, is celebrated for his ability to craft worlds imbued with deep mythology and profound moral questions. One of the most contentious elements in his legendarium is the origin of the orcs—a monstrous race of corrupted beings who represent evil’s foot soldiers. As a Christian conservative and Tolkien enthusiast, I have found his portrayal of orcs to be a fascinating exploration of free will, corruption, and morality. Yet, the origin of these creatures raises profound questions about creation, corruption, and redemption.

Tolkien’s writings on orcs evolved over time, leaving fans and scholars to debate their precise origins. Were they corrupted elves, twisted men, or soulless automatons created purely by evil? This question reveals Tolkien’s theological wrestling with themes of free will, original sin, and the nature of evil, topics that resonate deeply with my own journey from Islam to Christianity.

The Canonical Origins of Orcs

In The Silmarillion, we learn that the first orcs were elves, captured and corrupted by Melkor (later Morgoth), the first Dark Lord. This idea, articulated by the character Quenya, states:

“All those of the Quendi who came into the hands of Melkor…were put there in prison and by slow arts of cruelty were corrupted and enslaved.”

This account aligns with Tolkien’s Roman Catholic worldview, where evil cannot create but only corrupts what is good. The elves, the first-born of Ilúvatar, represent the pinnacle of created beauty, and their degradation into orcs is a symbolic fall from grace.

However, Tolkien expressed unease with this idea. In later writings, such as Morgoth’s Ring (Part 10 of The History of Middle-earth), he reconsidered whether orcs could be derived solely from elves. Tolkien grappled with the theological implications of a race doomed to evil without redemption or free will. Were orcs fully autonomous beings with souls? Or were they mere puppets of Morgoth and later Sauron?

Orcs and Free Will

One of Tolkien’s recurring themes is the tension between free will and the influence of external forces. For a Christian, the question of orcs touches on fundamental theological debates. If orcs were once elves, corrupted against their will, could they ever be redeemed? This parallels debates within Christianity about the nature of sin and grace.

In his letters, Tolkien wrote:

“I think that a moral being ‘perverted’ to evil would nevertheless be capable of some ‘good,’ or at least some neutral acts.” (The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien, Letter 153)

This view implies that orcs retain some measure of agency, despite their corruption. As someone who has left the Islamic worldview, where determinism often overshadows free will, I find Tolkien’s emphasis on moral choice profoundly liberating.

Racial and Ethical Implications

Tolkien’s depiction of orcs has not escaped criticism. Some modern readers accuse him of racial stereotyping, as orcs are often described with traits associated with non-European peoples. These critiques ignore the fact that Tolkien vehemently opposed racial superiority theories, as evidenced by his scathing rebuke of Nazi racial ideology in the 1930s.

Tolkien himself clarified:

“The notion that the orcs are wholly and entirely evil is a stark oversimplification, as with all beings in Middle-earth.” (The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien, Letter 210)

This statement underscores Tolkien’s nuanced approach to morality. Orcs, while embodying evil, are not caricatures. They are tragic figures, much like the fallen Islamic empires that once persecuted my ancestors. Their story is a cautionary tale of what happens when power corrupts and spiritual truths are rejected.

Conclusion

The origin of orcs in Tolkien’s canon is a microcosm of the larger themes of his legendarium: the struggle between good and evil, the corrupting nature of sin, and the hope for redemption. While Tolkien never fully resolved the theological and philosophical questions surrounding orcs, his writings invite readers to grapple with these issues themselves.

As a former Muslim who found redemption in Christianity, I see parallels between the orcs' corruption and humanity's fall into sin. Just as Tolkien's orcs raise questions about the possibility of redemption, so too does my journey remind me that no one is beyond the reach of grace.

---

References

1. Tolkien, J.R.R. The Silmarillion. Edited by Christopher Tolkien, HarperCollins, 1977.
2. Tolkien, J.R.R. The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien. Edited by Humphrey Carpenter, Houghton Mifflin, 1981.
3. Tolkien, J.R.R. Morgoth’s Ring. Edited by Christopher Tolkien, HarperCollins, 1993.
4. Carpenter, Humphrey. J.R.R. Tolkien: A Biography. Houghton Mifflin, 1977.
5. Flieger, Verlyn. Splintered Light: Logos and Language in Tolkien’s World. Kent State University Press, 2002.
6. Shippey, Tom. The Road to Middle-earth. HarperCollins, 2003.
7. Drout, Michael D.C. J.R.R. Tolkien Encyclopedia: Scholarship and Critical Assessment. Routledge, 2007.
8. Chance, Jane. Tolkien’s Art: A Mythology for England. University Press of Kentucky, 2001.
9. Birzer, Bradley J. J.R.R. Tolkien’s Sanctifying Myth: Understanding Middle-earth. ISI Books, 2003.
10. Duriez, Colin. The J.R.R. Tolkien Handbook: A Comprehensive Guide to His Life, Writings, and World of Middle-earth. Baker Books, 1992.
11. Rosebury, Brian. Tolkien: A Cultural Phenomenon. Palgrave Macmillan, 2003.
12. Wood, Ralph C. The Gospel According to Tolkien: Visions of the Kingdom in Middle-earth. Westminster John Knox Press, 2003.
13. Tolkien, J.R.R. The History of Middle-earth. Edited by Christopher Tolkien, HarperCollins, 1983–1996.
14. Dickerson, Matthew, and Jonathan Evans. Ents, Elves, and Eriador: The Environmental Vision of J.R.R. Tolkien. University Press of Kentucky, 2006.
15. Fonstad, Karen Wynn. The Atlas of Middle-earth. HarperCollins, 1991.
16. Fimi, Dimitra. Tolkien, Race and Cultural History: From Fairies to Hobbits. Palgrave Macmillan, 2009.
17. Honegger, Thomas. "Tolkien’s Creation of the Orcs." Tolkien Studies, vol. 3, 2006, pp. 153–171.
18. Shippey, Tom. “Orcs, Wraiths, Wights: Tolkien’s Evil Creatures.” Journal of Tolkien Research, vol. 4, no. 1, 2017.
19. Burns, Marjorie. "Perilous Realms: Tolkien, Lewis, and the Land of Faerie." Mythlore, vol. 26, 2007, pp. 9–18.
20. Robinson, George. The Body of Middle-earth: The Mythology of Tolkien’s Elves and Men. Routledge, 2011.