An Analysis of LDS Church Claims on Native American Origins: Middle Eastern and Eurasian Genetic Links

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS Church) has long held the belief, rooted in the Book of Mormon, that Native Americans are descendants of the ancient Israelites. This assertion has been a subject of considerable debate and skepticism, particularly among mainstream historians and scientists who generally support the theory that Native Americans migrated exclusively from East Asia via the Bering Strait. However, emerging genetic evidence suggests that a substantial portion of Native American ancestry can be traced back to Middle Eastern and Eurasian origins, lending some credence to the LDS Church's controversial claims.

Historical and Theological Context

The LDS Church's narrative, as presented in the Book of Mormon, suggests that ancient Israelites migrated to the Americas around 600 BCE, and their descendants became the Native American populations encountered by European settlers. This perspective has been criticized due to the dominant archaeological and genetic consensus that points to a purely East Asian origin for Native Americans. Yet, a closer examination of recent genetic studies reveals a more complex ancestry for these populations.

Genetic Evidence for Middle Eastern and Eurasian Ancestry

A growing body of genetic research has uncovered evidence of a non-East Asian component in the genetic makeup of Native Americans. One of the significant studies in this area is the research led by David Reich at Harvard Medical School, which found that Native American populations contain genetic markers from a population known as the Ancient North Eurasians (ANE). This group is believed to have contributed to the genetic pool of both Europeans and Native Americans .

Moreover, another study conducted by Eske Willerslev and colleagues at the University of Copenhagen found genetic links between Native American populations and peoples from the Near East and Europe. This research indicates that a significant portion of Native American ancestry comes from a population that lived in Siberia around 24,000 years ago and had genetic ties to both Europeans and Middle Easterners .

Implications for the LDS Church's Claims

These findings suggest that the genetic heritage of Native Americans is more diverse than previously thought, including substantial contributions from populations outside East Asia. While this does not directly validate the LDS Church's narrative of an Israelite migration to the Americas, it does provide a plausible genetic framework that supports the idea of Middle Eastern influences in the ancient Americas.

The presence of Middle Eastern genetic markers among Native Americans may also align with other archaeological and linguistic evidence suggesting pre-Columbian trans-oceanic contacts. Such evidence includes similarities in agricultural practices, artifact styles, and even linguistic parallels between the ancient Near East and pre-Columbian American civilizations .

Conclusion

The traditional view that Native Americans are solely descended from East Asian populations is increasingly challenged by genetic evidence showing significant contributions from Ancient North Eurasians and populations with ties to the Near East. While this complex ancestry does not confirm the specifics of the LDS Church's teachings, it opens the door for a re-evaluation of ancient migrations and cultural exchanges in pre-Columbian America. As genetic research continues to evolve, it may provide further insights that bridge the gap between theological narratives and scientific understanding, offering a more nuanced view of the origins of Native American peoples.

---

References

1. Reich, David et al. (2012). "Reconstructing Native American population history." Nature, 488, 370-374. link
2. Willerslev, Eske et al. (2014). "Genome sequence of a 24,000-year-old individual from the Yana RHS site in Siberia." Nature, 505, 87-91. link
3. Raghavan, Maanasa et al. (2014). "Upper Palaeolithic Siberian genome reveals dual ancestry of Native Americans." Nature, 505, 87-91. link
4. Lazaridis, Iosif et al. (2016). "Genomic insights into the origin of farming in the ancient Near East." Nature, 536, 419-424. link
5. Sorenson, John L. (1985). "An Ancient American Setting for the Book of Mormon." Deseret Book Company. link