Wednesday, October 4, 2023

Why LDS Polygamy and Joseph Smith Historian Left and Came Back to the LD...


The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, commonly known as the LDS Church or the Mormon Church, has a complex and fascinating history. One of the most controversial aspects of this history is the practice of polygamy during the 19th century and the life of Joseph Smith, the faith's founding prophet. In this two-part series, we will explore the journey of a historian who left the LDS Church due to doubts surrounding these issues and ultimately returned, finding renewed faith and conviction in the process.

The Complex History of Polygamy:

Polygamy, the practice of having multiple wives, is a topic that has intrigued and perplexed many, both inside and outside the LDS Church. It's essential to understand that polygamy was practiced by a minority of early Mormons during a specific period in the church's history. While it is not a current doctrine of the LDS Church, it remains a historical part of its past.

The historian we are focusing on, whom we will refer to as "John," initially struggled with the historical accounts of polygamy within the church. Like many others, he found it challenging to reconcile his understanding of the faith with the historical practice of polygamy by early church leaders.

John's Initial Departure:

In the early 2000s, John began to immerse himself in the historical records and documents related to Joseph Smith and the early church. As he delved deeper into the history, he encountered unsettling information about Joseph Smith's involvement in polygamy. The plural marriages of Joseph Smith to multiple women, including some who were already married to other men, raised questions and doubts in John's mind.

These discoveries led John to question his faith and ultimately led to his decision to leave the LDS Church. Like many who have faced faith crises, he felt a profound sense of disillusionment and needed time to reevaluate his beliefs.

The Importance of Historical Context:

As John stepped away from the LDS Church, he continued to study Mormon history independently. He soon discovered that understanding the historical context of polygamy and Joseph Smith's life was crucial to making sense of these controversial issues.

Polygamy was practiced by a relatively small number of early church members and leaders, and it occurred during a period of intense persecution and upheaval in the church's history. This historical context, marked by challenges, migrations, and the search for religious freedom, helps explain why polygamy emerged as a practice within the church.

Additionally, John began to appreciate that Joseph Smith's life was more complex than he initially realized. Joseph's role as a religious leader, prophet, and pioneer was fraught with challenges and personal struggles. John started to recognize that while Joseph Smith was a remarkable and inspired leader, he was also a product of his time, grappling with the same complexities and imperfections as any historical figure.

Conclusion:

John's journey out of and back to the LDS Church is a testament to the power of seeking a deeper understanding of history, context, and faith. In part two of this series, we will delve further into John's reevaluation of his beliefs and how he found a renewed sense of faith and conviction within the LDS Church.

Ultimately, John's story highlights the importance of grappling with challenging aspects of history and faith and the potential for reconciliation and growth that can come from such introspection. It serves as a reminder that faith is a personal journey, and each individual's path is unique.

No comments: